Slice of PIE
What is a Psychologically Informed Environment (PIE)? And what does it look like across the worlds of sport, business, the military, education, the performing arts and many other performance fields? With 19 years working in marketing strategy for blue chip companies and 11 years training towards Sports and Performance Psychology chartership (CPsychol - achieved in Jan 2024), I am seeking to find what each domain can learn from the other. To do so, I'm speaking to high performance experts, psychologists and those at the forefront of leadership, teamwork and organisational psychology research. #SliceofPIE Website: www.petejackson.co.uk
Slice of PIE
#39 Performing Under Pressure - Dr. Paul Mansell
Use Left/Right to seek, Home/End to jump to start or end. Hold shift to jump forward or backward.
This week’s episode is with Dr Paul Mansell: Proud Wolves fan, former teacher who transitioned into the world of sport psychology – now a lecturer, researcher, podcaster and most recently co-author of the fantastic book ‘Performing under pressure: Conversations with those that know’ alongside University of Staffordshire colleague and former Slice of PIE guest, Professor Matt Slater.
This episode focuses not just on the recently released book, but the 100+ episodes of the Performing Under Pressure Podcast that have inspired it’s pages, and Paul’s outlook on performing under pressure.
There’s a section of the conversation around 24 mins in, where we discuss our favourite “Try This Now” actionable tip from the book, Paul shares three of his and I share my favourite one – and Paul and Matt would love to know what your favourite parts of the book are – so if you do pick up a copy, then feel free to reach out to Paul and Matt… I know they’d love to hear from you.
Buy the book (UK)
https://hawksmoorpublishing.com/book/performing-under-pressure-conversations-with-those-that-know
Buy the book (USA)
Buy the book (AUS)
https://www.amazon.com.au/Performing-Under-Pressure-Conversations-Those/dp/1915855535
Listen to the Performing Under Pressure Podcast
Apple: https://podcasts.apple.com/gb/podcast/university-of-staffordshires-performing-under/id1728680321
Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/2UVgbxrwlSJKHax8CmsDOc
YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLkHj6Jg646IV_4CpYQfuX8p2AH98Tcn_g
You can follow Paul here:
LinkedIn:
linkedin.com/in/dr-paul-mansell-94ab9113b
University of Staffordshite:
Hello
Intro
SPEAKER_00and welcome back to the Slice of Pie podcast. Look, you know the deal. The pie is the psychologically informed environment. What we're trying to do is the impossible task of defining what it is. And during this fantastic failure, we'll at least hopefully further our understanding of what it might look like in sport, in business, or in any environment where performance and well-being are on the agenda. This week's episode is with Dr. Paul Mansell. First and foremost, he's a proud Wolves fan, but behind that Wolves fan, there's a former teacher who transitioned into the world of sports psychology, and now a lecturer, researcher, podcaster, and most recently co-author of the fantastic book Performing Under Pressure Conversations with Those That Know, which he co-authored alongside University of Staffordshire colleague and former Slicer Pie guest, Professor Matt Slater. And today's episode focuses not just on the recently released book, but the 100 plus episodes of the Performing Under Pressure podcast that have inspired its pages and Paul's outlook on Performing Under Pressure in general. There's a section of the conversation, you'll find it probably around 24 minutes in, I'll try and bookmark it where we discuss our favourite try this now actionable tip from the book. Paul shares three of his and I share my favourite one as well. And Paul and Matt would love to know what your favourite parts of the book are. So if you do end up picking up a copy, then please feel free to reach out to Paul and Matt. I know they'd love to hear from you all. So without further ado, let's get into the episode with Dr. Paul Mansell. Right,
Interview
SPEAKER_00well, this is a different experience for the Slice of Pie podcast because I'm not in my home office, or what I think is a home office, which is actually my daughter's nursery, which we're still converting into a home office, doing an episode over Zoom, but I'm actually in an actual podcast studio with a really exciting guest. We're at Staffordshire University, we're with Dr. Paul Mansell. We're going to talk about the book that he's just released with Matt Slater. And we're, as I said, we're in an actual studio, it's all very exciting. We've just recorded an episode of his podcast where I blathered on for an hour, and now I get to let him surface some much more interesting and insightful content, and I get to ask the questions. Paul, thanks so much for having me up here. How are you doing?
SPEAKER_01Pete, yeah, it's great, great to meet you properly, great to spend this time with you, and um yeah, really glad that you could come up to Stoke on Trent today and record two episodes for for the price of one.
SPEAKER_00Always love coming up. Came up for the conference uh about a month ago, and that was spectacular. Did a LinkedIn post on everything that I learnt from it if people are interested in. Um love coming up here. The whole staff are just always so brilliant, so giving their time, so insightful. Really excited to talk about the book. I have it in my hand right here. Performing Under Pressure. Conversations with those that know, based on I think 80, the first 80 episodes plus the bonus hundredth, is that right, with Connor?
SPEAKER_01That's exactly right. Connor
SPEAKER_00Cody. Uh released recently. I managed to get uh a copy and have torn through it, particularly the um the try it now bits at each of the chapter. I'm loving it and would encourage anyone listening to have a look at it. That's probably the big thing that's happening in your professional life at the moment. But over to you if there's anything else that you want to signpost to people, the book, any other initiatives worth signposting.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so first of all, Pete, thank you for your kind words about the book. It's been a real privilege and pleasure to spend the last two years writing that. It's genuinely longer than my PhD thesis. So the book is a hundred and eighteen thousand words, it's a real deep dive into the the complex and varied topic that is performing under pressure. So, yeah, that's occupied a lot of my time. The podcast, of course, is an ongoing um thing that we're continuing to roll with. And in fact, probably since the book has come out, we're probably even busier.
SPEAKER_00I
SPEAKER_01don't know if the two things are are related, but I'm in the midst of a spell now where I've recorded five episodes in the last week.
SPEAKER_00Alright.
SPEAKER_01It's a real pleasure to sit opposite people like yourself and the other guests because every single time I do that, it's the best form of CPD that I could give myself. So, yeah, the podcast is occupying a lot of my time.
SPEAKER_00Keeping your editors busy.
SPEAKER_01Keeping the editor busy, yeah, absolutely. And um I'm definitely not complaining about this at all. It's my choice. I want to keep driving it, and I'll continue to do that while I continue learning. So I can't imagine that stopping anytime soon. And then I suppose the other thing that's keeping me busy, apart from family life, is research. I love research. I see it as a real pleasurable part of my job, in addition to the teaching here on campus as well. So there's some exciting things we're doing in the world of mentoring at the moment,
SPEAKER_00right
SPEAKER_01in in professional football, both in this country and abroad. Um, a few other projects ongoing as well. So we're we're dipping our toe into the water of working with parents as well. So, yeah, the podcast and the re and research are probably the two things that I'm enjoying and and doing most of at the moment.
SPEAKER_00Good stuff. Well, let's get stuck into the book, shall we? It is a banger, and I would encourage anyone to pick it up because it's just beautifully structured. Every chapter ends in an ing, so it's really active. And you can not only can you, I mean, I'm a badger, so I'm reading it front to back, but you could just pick up this book and just dive into a chapter that is relevant to what you're dealing with in your life at the moment, whether it's believing or whether it's rest and recovery or whether it's thinking in a rational way, etc. And then every chapter ends with a summary and a try it now section, which actually I have been using some of these this week. I'd like to start by asking, what has this book, the endeavour of writing this and bringing this to life, brought to your life?
SPEAKER_01Less free time for a for a start. Uh but yeah, that's definitely not a a complaint. I mean, it's been tough, you know, to to do it. I've ended up doing work in airport lounges, on planes, on holiday sometimes. But that's never from a position of having to do it. It's always been from a position of wanting to, which has probably annoyed some of the people around me at times. Uh, but yeah, um that's the first thing I'd say. What else has it given me? New skills. I've never published a book before. I've written academic papers, but we were very conscious, like you've just alluded to, there, that this has got to be the kind of book that anybody can just pick up and get stuck into. So of course it's underpinned by literature and that academic undertone, as you'd expect, you know, with someone like Professor Matt Slater involved in in the project. So yeah, I've learned how to write, I think. Um you know, it for a different purpose and for a different audience. It's I mean, probably the the biggest thing is the connections that it's that it's given me. So we recorded our first episode with the TNT sport presenter Matt Smith, who anchors the Champions League coverage in the past. We recorded that in October 2023, and since then we've pretty much recorded at least one episode a month.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01So you can imagine all the people that I've come into contact with, some of the great minds. Of course, some people you never have that kind of long-lasting follow-up of a relationship with, and that's fine. People are busy, but I would say that I've made genuine friends as a result of people I've met on the podcast. And the connections have probably led to research as well, which I'll talk about more in a bit. But yeah, I've met some great people, and I'm really grateful for the chance to you know be sat having that protected time to talk about these kind of topics for for an hour at a time.
SPEAKER_00Fantastic. I mean, there's you know something that you said there around you know, working in airport lounges, but not doing it from a place of oh,
SPEAKER_01I've
SPEAKER_00got to get this this thing out. It's the old cheesy average as adage, isn't it? When you love what you do, you never work a day in your life because you know it's just something you're paying attention to at that point in time, and I suppose, like you say, you just have to manage expectations of others around you. Um and yeah, interesting about the kind of writing for a slightly different purpose, kind of wider audience. What what has that kind of looked like for you in terms of like how you're treating a certain passage? You're having to kind of put your mindset out of I'm writing for someone who's on the editorial board of an academic journal and how are they going to think about this versus someone who could be a doctor or a teacher or an athlete, etc. Talk talk me through that.
SPEAKER_01I guess one of the advantages for that, for anybody that picks up the book and reads it, it's quite quote-heavy from the participants for a start. So the majority of the words really aren't mine or aren't Matt's letters, but that's the whole point, you know, in terms of why did we want to do the book? We wanted to do the book because the people that have sat in the studio and opened up themselves to talk about performing under pressure are people that have said some fantastic things and can add to everybody's knowledge about it. So that that was one thing, and I guess that had a challenge in itself about okay, you've got 80 plus one episodes. How do you decide on which quotes to put in? So that took a lot of time listening back to episodes again, which is a great form of CPD for yourself, you know, to listen back to the conversations from that perspective. But I think it took quite a few drafts, if I'm honest. I uh shared drafts with people who weren't academics and asked them to take a look at it because I think you know if they could take something from it, then I knew that I was pitching it at the right level.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And obviously, working in partnership with uh with Matt Slater allowed us to kind of check and challenge each other. Is this coming across as too academic? Is it too research heavy? So yeah, I'd say through those few processes, hopefully we've struck the right balance of being readable for anybody, but still having that undertone that when you're reading it, you know that not only is it people's experiences, but those experiences are supported by evidence as well. Yeah, and that's what hopefully what gives it the value.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, yeah. I I think that I am not just saying this because you've invited me up here and you've allowed me to record in your lovely podcast studio, but I think it has really struck that that balance, and we will get into some of the specifics in a sec. I just want to just take a step back for a second because the book is based on this podcast journey that you've been on that you've just mentioned that has a kind of three, four-year journey, now about way over a hundred plus conversations. But what are the the the things that have surprised you or have really punctuated your journey with this podcast? It could be the hosting skills, it could be the the technical side, it could be getting messages from people in s in Sweden talking about what they've taken from it. What are the kind of everlasting things that you've taken away from this this journey in terms of skills, in terms of learning, in terms of connection with with people?
SPEAKER_01I think what I've learned is the is the value of learning, you know that even though, as you said, we've done, I think, at the time of recording this, about 135 episodes, I've still taken something from every single guest. There's still new topics that have been brought up, there's still new phrases that guests are saying that are changing the way that I think about things and I'm then using in my teaching. So it's reinforced the value of learning. You mentioned the technical skills before I started this podcast. I had never had any experience at all, so I'm very grateful to the people here at the university who've helped me along the way. And I definitely wouldn't say I'm a technical whiz or expert, but yeah, that's been a challenge, and I've hopefully mastered the very basics of that now. Enough to get by. The next frontier that people keep asking us about is oh, why don't you make it into a video-based podcast as well? We've thought carefully about that, and for now, I don't think it's an option in terms of time, effort, logistics, platform. We don't want to stray too far from what the whole purpose of this is about is to share conversations. And I think that can be done perfectly fine on an audio basis. What else have I taken or or learned on the journey? I guess I've been quite surprised by some of the themes that have come up that perhaps I didn't realise were so crucial in performing under pressure. So I'll give you one quick example of that. Episode 70, and this actually has been that important that we've created a whole chapter to it in the book. We were lucky to be joined in the studio by the founder of Optimum Performance, Jack McMillan.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01The word expert is banded around a lot, but Jack is a genuine expert in his field of breath work. He knows everything about it, he knows the science of it, he knows the theory of it, but he knows how to deliver it as well. Why does that surprise me? It surprised me about the appetite that so many athletes seem to have now to include that, whether that's part of their pre-event preparation in the moment as well, and also from a more kind of well-being and rest perspective to regulate themselves.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, I I suppose it's allowed me to reconsider topics that relate to performing under pressure that I probably didn't realise were so important.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. Such a great to get such a mix of experiences from one initiative, whether it's CPD, whether it's pushing yourself and your own technical skills, the hosting skills we were talking off-air, in-between podcasts, about how quite often you're holding three things, four things in your head at once when you're you're hosting and asking people questions, but also having to listen to them and listen to their answer, but also think what would the audience like to listen to at the same time? And oh, by the way, there's someone else who's gonna be Matt Smith's gonna be in the studio in an hour's time. Um, so we better hurry up. So it's amazing that you've managed to take all of that. And the breath work was a part of the workshop, part of the conference that ran about a month ago that I attended. I did do Jack's breathwork workshop, and it it is amazing how quickly athletes connect with it. It's so tangible, it's so immediate. Obviously, there's some very big names in our industry that have talked about it for many years, whether it's Ken Ravitza, there's videos of Kobe Bryant talking about it. If you look at the The Last Dance documentary, you can see all the Chicago Bulls guys doing their meditative work with um who was the famous coach? Was it uh Phil Jackson?
SPEAKER_01Yes.
SPEAKER_00Phil Jackson, who was he I think he was a Buddhist, wasn't he? Like practicing Buddhist. Um so I think that that mixture of something being so immediate, so tangible, but also role modelled by some of the biggest athletes in the world really helps kind of light the fire and kind of make it something that has a bit of momentum in the industry.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely, yeah. It really does help when people who are professional athletes who are really successful speak openly on podcasts like like this about the utility of it. So it just makes people think if Michael Jordan's using it, then maybe it's something I should give a try as well.
SPEAKER_00Yeah. So we've talked there about a couple of pieces of the the puzzle that relate to performing under pressure that during the podcast journey you've either haven't spent much time looking at or maybe you looked at that literature five, ten years ago, but it's now been refreshed and there's more stuff to pick into. And that's great. But are there any fundamental things that have changed your understanding or your perspective on performing under pressure that have come from the podcast journey?
SPEAKER_01The number one thing I would say is the value of mentoring in professional football. Sports psychologists and coaches and parents do a fantastic job so often of supporting athletes on a psychological level. They've got different ways of doing that, depending on their role, of course. And in my answer here, I'm absolutely not belittling the value that other people bring in terms of that. But I quickly came to realise on the podcast, some of the professional footballers and recently retired professional footballers that were sat opposite me, had such value from their lived experience of going through a junior to senior transition, retiring from sport, playing for their country. I almost felt an obligation to try and find a way to get somebody like, say Matt Jarvis, for instance, promoted to the Premier League with Wolves. West Ham's record signing in the Premier League at the time, played for England at Wembley under Fabio Capello. He's got such value. Can I find a way to legitimately and from an evidence-based scientific perspective, get him working with people who are maybe 16, 17 years old going through their transition because his experiences are valuable and should be shared. So that kind of led to the birth of a project that we've run for two and a half years now called Mentoring Beyond Talent. And without a shadow of doubt, without the podcast, that project would not have happened. As I mentioned, that's been running for two and a half years. We've got some incredibly strong data that suggests that the mentoring approach is valued, desirable, and useful by young players. And one of the reasons, or some of the reasons I should say, is because they enjoy listening to people who've been in their shoes before, they find that relatable. They see somebody like Matt Jarvis as credible, they value external support. And again, I'm absolutely not saying that a psychologist who's embedded in a sports organisation can't give that. But I'm just saying this is another way to support somebody. And yeah, without the podcast, I don't think that research would have happened. And what surprised me, I guess I know this because I've written a couple of papers on it that are currently under review as we record this now. There's no previous literature that has examined the role of mentoring in helping young players make that step up from being an academy footballer to a professional footballer. And I found that so surprising because anecdotally we see and hear so many interviews of players talking informally about oh, I had this mentor
SPEAKER_00and
SPEAKER_01this mentor really helped me in my journey. So yeah, that that's something I really was ignited from this podcast, and we're going to continue to push that forward because we really see the benefit of it in terms of the data.
SPEAKER_00Fantastic. Funnily enough, the last but one conversation that I had on this podcast was with Dr. Brian Hemings and Dr. Jonathan Katz, which is all about mentoring. And one of the things that came up in that conversation is about the impartiality of someone who is purely external and the fact that they they might have an affinity for you, but they don't have skin in the game in terms of your career and and your life and how valuable that is to have a sounding board that is truly impartial and to have a safe space to share things, which is speaking to a lot of ingredients that are in the the wider, not just applied sports psychology literature, but the applied psychology literature in in general, in terms of safety to be able to talk, to build a relationship with another human being that you see as credible and the things that they're saying you put in high esteem. So it's really amazing that projects have come from the podcast. I'm
'Try This Now' Chapters
SPEAKER_00gonna ask you now about the specific parts at the end of the chapters, the try this now sections, which are great. I'm gonna ask you whether you have a favourite try this now, and then selfishly I'm gonna tell you what mine is afterwards because I'm I've actually used it this week and I think it's been great. But out of all of the this is maybe a tough question to ask, but I have given you some time to prepare, so I think you'll have an answer. Is there a try this now in one of the the sections of the book that really stands out for you? Do you have a a favourite or uh one that has st stood out for you?
SPEAKER_01Okay, I'll be a little bit greedy and maybe try and give three if that's okay.
SPEAKER_00The more the merrier.
SPEAKER_01I'll be fascinated to hear yours in a in a moment as well, because yeah, I'd encourage anybody to tell me and Matt Slater what you are using from the book. You know, that's one of the reasons that we wrote it in the first place to To help people. So my three things are probably this control mapping. Why am I saying that? The frequency of times where that's come up in the conversation means I can't ignore it as something that's really valuable. What do I mean by control mapping? Being aware of the factors that you can and can't control and turning your time and your effort and attention to the controllable factors and having the acknowledgement and the readiness to park things that you can't control. Why am I saying this is my number one? Well, like I said, the amount of times it's been mentioned. But you don't have to sit down and draw this out on a piece of paper. You can be on the way to a meeting in the car, and you can be thinking to yourself, okay, prior to this meeting, what are the things that are in my control?
SPEAKER_00And
SPEAKER_01equally, what are the things that are uncontrollable? It can be done in your head, anytime, anywhere, and it relates to so many pressure events. My second one, and this is something I'm using a lot in my personal life, which is probably because of the podcast, is gratitude.
SPEAKER_00Oh right.
SPEAKER_01So every night my daughter, my youngest daughter is 12, and when I put her to bed, we both write in her diary things that we've been grateful for or have made us smile every day.
SPEAKER_00That is lovely.
SPEAKER_01Now it's an embedded habit in our house. If um if I haven't done it quickly enough, she's soon shouting, Dad, like get the book out.
SPEAKER_00Keeping you accountable.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, exactly. And the re one of the reasons I bring it up is because in the moment, of course, that can give you a great warm feeling at the end of the day. But I think you can use gratitude all through the day, even when something's hard. So for instance, if you are teaching and you've got a three-hour session and that can be quite demanding on your mental resources, instead of thinking to yourself, Oh, I've got to teach, this is hard, there's so many other things I need to be doing. Actually, stopping and thinking, hang on a second, I'm really grateful that I get the chance to impart my knowledge with students and to learn from them as well. So I think gratitude is not something that that should be done just at the start or end of the day, and in a diary, in a journal, that has value for sure. But I think of all almost formed like a constant gratitude mindset, if if that's such a thing.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01Where I'm trying to do it all day, every day. And the final thing, I guess I would go to something that maybe maybe this has got a bit of bias here because this is what I built the early part of my career on. It's this idea of stress mindset. We've all got trait beliefs about the nature of stress. I guess if you asked a hundred people on the streets of Stoke on Trent, do you like stress or is stress good? I guess more people than not would say it's bad. But we know from our research that you can look at stress in a more balanced way. And when you do, it has a whole host of associated benefits. So the try this now, where does that come in? Even though stress mindset is very trait belief, you can apply that in the moment. When you've got a pressure event coming up or something that matters to you, you're bound to get butterflies
SPEAKER_00at
SPEAKER_01increased heart rate, increased breathing rate. These are stress responses that we all get. And I think Yeah, exactly. It's a story you tell yourself about those responses. And I'm highlighting this because you don't have to be an England international footballer to do this. You can be a primary school teacher, you can be someone who works in marketing, giving a big uh pitch. Having a narrative in your head that these butterflies are not a sign of weakness or not damaging. In fact, they're part of my body's way of getting me ready for an event. They're actually facilitating my response to the situation. I think that's massive.
SPEAKER_00One of the threads there I'd like to pull on is gratitude. First of all, I think there's a wider notion there, which is we're all the the main what was it, the main character of our own lives, right? And it it's it's so natural to spend most of that time thinking about your next step or your next want, your next desire. And obviously things change if you get married or if you have kids, that that can be sometimes a big precipitator of worldviews changing. But just even if if you're not, the other people in the world that matter to you, whether it's your teammates, whether it's your colleagues, whether it's your family, thinking about either being grateful for them or even thinking about things that you can do for someone else kind of brings you out of you for a little second. And just because we spend a lot of time thinking about us and what we need to do next. So actually having those little moments where we can break out of it either to do something for someone else or to be grateful for the things in our life, I think is is really interesting. But there's a little thread that I want to pull on, which is gratitude used as a reframe for things that are happening in your house in your life. So you mentioned there if you know if your day's not going well, you can use gratitude as a nice reframe. Brene Braun has written a lot about this, the tipping point between using reframes like that in an adaptive way or helpful way versus using them as like a kind of an at least to paper over things that are genuinely quite challenging in your life. I wonder whether you have a perspective on that. I think the the example she uses there's a kind of a YouTube TED talk video where it's kind of animated, you know, someone's experiencing some something, but then there's another person going, well, at least you don't, you know, at least you've got running water, etc. Um, and sometimes that can you know paper over you know actual worries that maybe you need to kind of pay attention to and not repress or or push away. So I think yeah, it's just something that I wrote down there during what you were saying, and I wonder whether you have a kind of a perspective on those those two ways of using it.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, I think it's a very worthy point that you've raised for a start. But I think where I'm coming from with this is that in every situation, no matter if it goes wrong, no matter if it's hard, there are things that you can still take from it. So even if you lose a football match or deliver a a lesson that's not what you want it to be, there are still things that you can say, okay, well, at least I've had that experience. No, what are the lessons that we can learn from it for the future?
SPEAKER_00So
SPEAKER_01I think people often um look at the word optimist and think, oh, that's all just thinking positive.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But I think you can think helpfully instead of thinking positive. So yeah, I think it relates to any experience, good or bad. Okay, looking beyond the result, looking beyond the outcome, what have I learned, what have I developed, what can I take forward from this situation?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. No, I like that. I think for me there's there's a gap in between some experiences and then what you choose to do next, where I like to give my maybe it's just a personal thing, I like to give myself permission to just feel whatever I'm feeling in that moment before I then apply what I know logically are the helpful rational thinking or reframes or or whatever. So if I've lost a match or if a pitch has gone badly, or if I've just had a bad day, giving myself the permission to feel that for a bit and know that that's okay before I accept that also feeling that forever is also not helpful as well, and that potentially that's a good time to use the reframe, to use the piece of gratitude, or to you know to put focus on the next thing.
SPEAKER_01Absolutely. Yeah, I think you make a really good point there that it's alright to feel disappointed. We're not saying that, you know, after a setback, you don't have to instantly think, oh, that's okay, let's move on. It's having that balance, and I think balance is almost the answer to everything, really. But instead of choosing to focus all your attention and time and efforts on what went wrong, you do need to look at those, of course, if you want to improve. I think it's making a conscious and deliberate choice to ask yourself, well, what can you still take from it?
SPEAKER_00Yeah,
SPEAKER_01and how can you move yourself forward?
SPEAKER_00This slingshots on very nicely to my shall I just tell you my favourite try this now.
SPEAKER_01Please do.
SPEAKER_00Yep. So there's a section on belief and believing which primarily focuses on what you can do for yourself to promote belief in your own self-efficacy, self-confidence, but there's also a part of that section in the try it now where it puts the onus on you doing it for other people. So not just being an enabler of your own self-confidence, but actually taking the time to authentically and not in a sycophantic way, say to someone that you work with or in your family that you recognize something that they do that is good, or be the enabler or the catalyst for someone else to believe in themselves. And I just thought that was really powerful because again, we spend so much time thinking about ourselves. Um, we've got these daily opportunities to support and reinforce other people's strengths, and I think that's such a great tip to take from the book, and it has again that double whammy positive effect, it makes someone else feel bloody amazing about themselves and a strength that they're getting supported on, but also will naturally make you feel good as well because you've been a part in helping someone. So I thought that was a really good try this now.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, thank you for highlighting that. And I think on a practical level, I'll give two quick examples of how I tried to apply that recently. So I think maybe at university, when you're a student, it can be taken for granted sometimes that you'll just do good work. I had a student do a good piece of work on the master's programme for me recently.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01And I thought, do you know what? This warrants a private direct message on Teams to say, your work was great. Thank you for your effort. How's that gonna make that person feel? Hopefully it'll have an impact. And then another example, literally from yesterday, um, I was listening back to an episode just to just to check it before it was uploaded for the podcast. And it just struck me how good the guest was in terms of how she had communicated her thoughts and how interesting I found her. So I got my phone out and I just recorded a 30-second voice note. You were fantastic, and I think what's that taken out of my day to do that? But what impact could it have for that person?
SPEAKER_00Yeah. I love it. There was a I mentioned on our conversation earlier that I'd become an NFL badger recently, really paying attention to that. And I stumbled across this YouTube video about an NFL coach talking about their philosophy in developing players, developing young players who've just come out of the draft. NFL's new to them, they're picking up everything technically, tactically, culturally, in order to try and build a career, get that second contract. And he talked about this 90, his 90-10 rule as a coach, which was 90% of the time I'm going to give feedback which is on the strengths of the player and really promote the things that they're doing well and signpost the things that they're doing well, and then 10% of the time I'll be using that to identify things that they can improve. And it came from this place of everyone knows that they want to improve, everyone's there to improve, but if coaches are spending the whole time talking about the things that you need to improve on, it creates this atmosphere and this climate of maybe I'm not that good. But the reality is they are the 1%, they are the 0.5% of players that have managed to get through high school, get through college, get drafted, and so they are good and they have got great traits, and and actually it's more beneficial, it's more useful to spend 90% of the time signposting the things that are going well, to encourage that rep to be the same, just like that next time, and then 10% of the time spent on because there's still that important portion where people want to improve, but it's getting that um that ratio right. So it just kind of struck me when you were you were talking. So on to the next question: the psychologically informed environment.
Thoughts on the PIE
SPEAKER_00So, what does the pie look like for you? What are the elements or ingredients you would want to bake into it? And are there any themes from the book that might be particularly relevant for a psychologically informed environment?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it's a a broad question, but a very important question, and I think there's probably no two environments that are the same. First of all, this can vary depending on the context, but I think there's a few I don't know if non-negotiables is the right word, but a few themes that should probably be evident in order to fulfil that psychologically informed environment. You're asking me to maybe rank them in terms of perform uh importance. I'd probably say where the leaders see the person before the athlete or the employee, where the leader is not just seeing that person as a a number on a spreadsheet or uh just somebody who's there to fulfil a task, but actually takes an active interest in them as a person. So that's probably my number one, and I think that has come up a lot on the podcast.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Probably the biggest influence on me in terms of that is that in episode 58 of our podcast, we spoke to former professional footballer Danny Schofield. Danny is now the assistant first team coach at Readin' Football Club, and he had the phrase, you're not a footballer, you're a human being who plays football. That's really stayed with me. And I think any environment where your leaders are thinking in that way can only benefit the players or the employees. So that's my first point.
SPEAKER_00Right.
SPEAKER_01Secondly, I would say an environment where psychological safety is encouraged and promoted. And what I mean by that is where mistakes are not treated by leaders as something where you need to go and punish people. But I wouldn't necessarily well, maybe I'd go as far to say as mistakes are encouraged to be made because that's how you learn. So in a psychologically safe environment, people are almost encouraged to make mistakes. Mistakes are treated not as this big, bad, evil thing. Failure is not treated as a dirty word, it's treated as something that can help you move forward on to wherever you're trying to go. And I think an important thing on the topic of this is where fears and concerns can be shared to leaders without fear of recrimination or is that gonna is that information gonna be passed on to people that I don't want it to be passed on to? So a psychologically safe environment would be key on my checklist of things. Maybe an answer that people wouldn't jump to so much, but I think it's important, is the actual physical design of a business, an institution. So I've worked at places, for instance, where there's a lot of separateness between this group of people and that group of people. But I'll give you a quick anecdote from an episode that isn't in the book because it missed the deadline.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01But fairly recently, actually, we were at Redin Football Club and we interviewed the CEO, Joe Jacobson.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01Joe is a former professional footballer himself, made over 400 appearances in his career. And even though he's in his 30s, he's now a CEO of um a major football club. And they've changed the organisation at Readin in two ways. So it used to be some people were based at the select car leasing stadium, used to be known as the Majaski, I think, back in the day. And some people were based at Bearwood, which is their training ground.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01So there's a separateness. So what what Joe and the owner decided to do was to bring everybody, no matter if you're in ticket sales, marketing, you're now working at the training ground. Because we're all here to try and get Reading Football Club three points on a Saturday. But also, interestingly, what each player has to do is sign in and sign out at the manager's office. This isn't done from a place of
SPEAKER_00It's not an 18th century mill working.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, you're not clocking on and clocking off. It's not like we're doing this to monitor what time you stayed here to. The point is they have to walk from either the canteen or the showers or the gym upstairs along the corridor to where the staff are based. Why do they do that? They have to do that so that they're having to walk through people who are working behind the scenes four or three points on a Saturday. It's creating conversations. So I think that physical design, a quick anecdote from the book. I think it was episode 59. We spoke to um a guy called Robbie Udberg, who was the head of performance at Chelsea Women.
SPEAKER_00Okay.
SPEAKER_01They had a period of extreme dominance in the WSL under the stewardship of Emma Hayes.
SPEAKER_00Yep.
SPEAKER_01What did they do? Uh uh at the training ground. They had a situation in the past where I think it was Emma's office, it
unknownwas
SPEAKER_01at the end of this corridor. And if you were seen walking down this corridor, it's you're doing like a walk of shame.
SPEAKER_00Oh.
SPEAKER_01Yeah. What's this player doing? Yeah.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01Um, so they changed that, and they I forget the exact layout, but Robbie and Emma worked together to redesign the training ground to facilitate conversations between people and to remove this awkwardness of going to the manager's office.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And yeah, I guess that means that people get to know each other. Like, we can all ask people in the corridor at work, how are you? Yeah, I'm alright, I'm fine. How are you? Yeah, I'm okay. Oh yeah, that's how they are, so they must be alright.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But I think if you can change the physical layout, it encourages conversations beyond surface level. And then when you have that relationship, it's like an invisible bond that makes you want to run the extra mile for that player. The final thing, and maybe on reflection, this could have been number one on my checklist. An environment where rational language is actively used and encouraged. So
SPEAKER_00Martin Turner Pagey to say that one, has he?
SPEAKER_01Well, Martin Turner's been a huge influence on my life and professional career. So um yeah, it's we're trying to avoid awfulising type language. We're trying to avoid frustration and tolerance. We're trying to promote rational preferences instead of demandingness.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And the reason I'm highlighting this is twofold. We know that irrational language, irrational beliefs, strongly associated to poor mental health. Not just my own studies, people like Martin, Andrew Wood, Stuart Carrington doing fantastic work in this space. So there's the well-being arm, but also there's the performance arm as well. Again, not just my own work, but others have found that irrational beliefs are associated with lower confidence, more performance anxiety. So if that language is being adopted through the organisation from the leader, I think it can filter down to everybody in the organisation, and it has that well-being and performance benefit, I believe. So I think studies are still needed to try and track that.
SPEAKER_00It'd
SPEAKER_01be an interesting study to design, so it would be good to link up maybe with Martin
SPEAKER_00on
SPEAKER_01that one. But yeah, those would be some of my thoughts, Pete, on how to create a psychologically informed environment.
SPEAKER_00Great. It's interesting how you can just writing down the the different elements there, you can see how some of these potentially interact.
SPEAKER_01Yeah.
SPEAKER_00But just really strikes you that having a rational climate with kind of a rational belief system running through an organization might help to promote psychological safety because there's less black and white dichotomous live or die thinking that are making people fearful for speaking up. And it reminds me of a passage in the book where is it Helen Richardson Walsh is is called out basically by one of the newbies in the the Britain hockey team for maybe not putting enough weight on an overhead hang, I think, something like that.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, yeah, yeah.
SPEAKER_00Um, and how the kind of the alarm bells were going off in her head immediately, like how how dare you kind of point this out, but then got to quite quickly actually, wait a second, as a cultural architect in this this team, how beneficial would it be if I really take this on board and really be curious about what this person is saying? Um, and I think she she mentioned actually, do you know what I think I probably could put a little bit more more weight on and how good is this going to be as a a role model for psychological safety within this team that I can take on board this feedback from someone who's so new?
SPEAKER_01Yeah, it it's a great story. Thank you for highlighting that. And I love the phrase cultural architects, and I certainly can't sit here and say, I invented it. I think it's Damien Hughes really that's used it a lot.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01But yeah, having the right types of people in an organization that can set the temperature, set the tone. Challenge things in a respectful way where people probably aren't falling in line with the expectations, I think that's a really important point that you make there that that definitely would contribute to a psychologically informed environment.
SPEAKER_00Good stuff. And speaking of challenging,
Cultural Influences
SPEAKER_00here's a challenge for you. It's the the last question now that we do on the podcast. We've had a myriad of answers from Paolo Coelho's The Alchemist to the movie The Matrix. Is there a a book, a podcast, movie, or TV show that has impacted you personally or or professionally?
SPEAKER_01Huge question. Okay,
SPEAKER_00it's big.
SPEAKER_01I'll try and give a bit of variety in my answer. So personally and professionally in my first answer, uh intertwined because I remember being a child watching Italian 90 and just being completely like this is an era, right, where there's no sky sports, there's no mobile phones, cable TV, I think, is about to burst on the scene and and sky sports and all that kind of stuff. As a young lad growing up in the black country, you've seen all these colours and scenes and music and goals coming on TV and you're like, wow, and the drama as well. You know, the penalty shootouts, England, Germany, Gascoins Tears, Bobby Robson, Roger Miller, the Cameroon striker.
SPEAKER_00Great dancing.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, Higita, the um Colombian goalkeeper. It was just like that's the thing, that's the one thing that has been the catalyst for my interest in sport, which has subsequently, of course, led me into this career. So my first one is the Italia 90 programme, and I know you know you you were quite a fan of uh Italian football from back in the day, right?
SPEAKER_00Oh yeah, yeah. Cazetta on a Saturday morning, James Richardson with an espresso in a piazza. Doesn't get better than that.
SPEAKER_01They don't make them like that anymore.
SPEAKER_00No. And Pavarotti as well for Italian 90, that's just the soundtrack.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, so without that, would I even be sat here working in sports psychology?
SPEAKER_00Sliding doors.
SPEAKER_01Exactly, yeah. So in terms of TV, show or programme, the whole of Italian 90, I'll give an academic book next. Probably Carol Dweck's mindset. This taught me that what you believed about yourself and the world influenced how you thought and behaved because of those beliefs, which probably was the catalyst for me to get in interested in REBT, which was probably the catalyst for me to come onto the master's programme here back in 2016 as a student. Based on that, I'd probably also recommend Martin Turner's excellent The Rational Practitioner. For me, as somebody who values and loves REBT, it's an absolute complete works of REBT and it's a practical use in sport.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01And then if I'm gonna give one that might be surprising actually. Um there's a book about the German goalkeeper Robert Enker.
SPEAKER_00I've read it. A Life
SPEAKER_01Too Short.
SPEAKER_00It's something else. Yeah.
SPEAKER_01The author I think is a guy called Ronald Reng.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I don't read many books more than once because it's already the next book that I want to read.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I've probably read this book three times.
SPEAKER_00Wow.
SPEAKER_01And it's so moving and so powerful. And I think the first time I read it, my daughters were a similar age to Robert Enker's. And I won't spoil the story for people that want to go and pick it up and listen, but it might have you in tears, actually, if you if you read it. And I think for me as a as a young dad at the time, it had just had that double impact.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01So yeah, Italia 90, Carol Dweck's Mindset, and A Life Too Short, which is um a biography of Robert Henker, the German and I think Barcelona international uh Barcelona goalkeeper.
SPEAKER_00Yeah, Ben Fieker, I think he was at for a for a wee bit as well. I mean, yeah, what a great array. Thank you for contributing those. We'll add those to the kind of Aladdin's cave of cultural and content trinkets that we're collecting on Slicer Pie. Related to Carol Direct mindset, my mum retired from being a head teacher a few years ago. She that book completely changed how she saw running her school. She had a little sign on the outside of her head teacher's office that said an expert is just a beginner who has practiced a lot.
SPEAKER_01And
SPEAKER_00there were tons of these little trinkets that she used to pop around school to kind of create this climate of growth mindset. There's lots of discussion, I think, within our industry and wider about you know kind of capturing those those things like specifically and scientifically. And I think aside from those conversations about how you're kind of capturing it and measuring it and stuff like that, the fact that that book has had such an impact, particularly within the education centre sense, and has you know driven people like my mum to to make changes and to to put things up around school to to help kind of create this this love of learning and this acceptance of things like failure or setbacks on the way to mastery, I think such a brilliant, uh brilliant thing. And then just in relationship uh in relation rather to uh Robert Enker, I had Pete Schneider on earlier in the year who's done a lot of work with RB Leipzig and works with professional footballers. And one of his big reflections from working in that that world, and really it shouldn't be surprising at all, is yes, people who are professional and do things for a living that other people would kill to do are in a very fantastic position in life and and in some sports, football, basketball, etc., there can be some incredible monetary benefits to that as well, which means they might never have to work again, and their grandkids might never have to work again, but they're still human and they're still susceptible to all of the the psychological spiritual challenges that human beings beings have, and I think that's really brought to the fore in that book. But yeah, thank you very much for for sharing all of those.
SPEAKER_01You're welcome, and I think how you sum that up there. Thinking about it now probably was one of the catalysts for me to go and study sports psychology and then go and go and do a PhD in it, but you just put that really well in terms of players like like Robert Enker, who were I think he was in the World Cup squad 2010.
SPEAKER_00Yes.
SPEAKER_01You know, he's at the the peak of his powers, but he wasn't immune to suffering difficulties, real difficulties and challenges, you know, at the same time. So I think it was an illuminating book and I'd really encourage people who are interested in sport psychology, performance, and just kind of like you know, people's stories.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01This is a great book.
SPEAKER_00Great. Right, if you're listening still, and I know about half of you have dropped off because I can see from the analytics, but those the half of you that are still here, go online, get that book, get a copy of Performing Under Pressure Conversations with Those That Know While You're At It. And Paul, thank you so much for for coming on. Thank you for inviting me up to your amazing studio and having these conversations. It's been much appreciated.
SPEAKER_01Yeah, no, thank thank you. First of all, thank you for your kind words about the book. It's really um you know, when you put so much into a book and then the big release comes, you've got this nervousness maybe about oh well what are people gonna think about it, especially people that you got so much respect for that you've written about in the book.
SPEAKER_00Yeah.
SPEAKER_01I'll give people a little tip in terms of getting hold of the book as we sit and record this now. If you order from Hawkstone Publishing, which is the the publisher of the book, it is cheaper than ordering it from Amazon, and that includes free postage and packaging in the UK. If you're an international listener, I believe it's on Amazon US and Amazon Australia. So it is you can get hold of it if you if you're living abroad. But the last thing I want to say to you, Pete, is just the respect I have for you as a podcaster. I know how hard it can be.
SPEAKER_00Good man.
SPEAKER_01Um to balance it's not just the conversation, that's not easy in itself, but it's the preparation, it's the reflection afterwards, it's the editing, it's the whole package. So, from someone who runs a podcast myself, respect to you for what you do and and keep up the great work.
SPEAKER_00Good man, I'll take it. Thanks, Paul.
SPEAKER_01You're welcome, thank you very much.
Reflection
SPEAKER_00Well, there we have it. A fascinating conversation with Dr. Paul Mansell, host of Staffordshire University's Performing Under Pressure podcast, and the author of a rather hefty new book of the same name, as we've just heard, 118,000 words longer than his PhD thesis. So, what can we take from our conversation? From revisiting the sports psychology literature you've not paid as much attention to, to the power of mentoring, from control mapping to gratitude, and from reframing our thoughts about having nerves, stress, or butterflies, to the importance of helping others recognise their own strengths. It was a conversation that offered plenty of practical takeaways, not just for those working in sport and performance psychology, but for anyone navigating the inevitable challenges that come from doing things that matter to us. A very applied conversation mirroring the applied nature of the book. And there were a few things that stood out. Firstly, the importance of remaining curious and being open to having your thinking changed. So, one of the things I really liked about Paul's reflections on writing the book was the process of revisiting areas of the literature that perhaps he had not had the time to explore as deeply or hadn't covered in many years. I think there's something important in that for all of us working in psychology, or just perhaps in general, it's easy to become comfortable with the areas we know well within our performance domain or within our vocational domain. And the approaches we regularly use and the theories we've built our practice around or our work around. But speaking to experts about what they actually value and pay attention to and use in their own performance environments can kind of open up some interesting new avenues. So for Paul, one of those areas was mentoring. The impact that mentoring could have on both performance and well-being really struck him, to the point that it prompted a whole new project and investment into the area via mentoring beyond talent. And it seems like the early findings are really encouraging with athletes seemingly valuing the opportunity to hear from people who've been in their shoes before. And there's something powerful about that relatability alongside the credibility that comes from listening to someone who's experienced similar challenges firsthand. The impact that mentors have in this system makes me think about other elements of the applied literature that might be facilitating these benefits, things like the link between engagement, rapport, and the relationship with knowledge transfer and facilitating change. I know there were other parts that we dug into as well, like breath work and breathing, elements of the literature that perhaps you paid attention to years back or just haven't gone as deep in before, that suddenly, when you pay attention to it or you have experts on the podcast talking about it, suddenly open your eyes to its potential in terms of helping performance and well-being. Secondly, it's not always about thinking positively, but thinking helpfully. So this quote from Paul cropped up in and around our discussion on the use of gratitude as a tool to use during challenging moments as a different way of seeing things. It struck me, as I mentioned in the interview, that there can be a difference between using gratitude as a genuinely helpful way of broadening our perspective and just kind of using it as a rather blunt at least tool, like, oh at least this is not happening to me. Reframe response to something that's upset us, frustrated us, or caused us distress. I think in the interview I refer to it as kind of papering over the cracks. Because sometimes we're really quick to reach for a reframe or a tool that we don't actually give ourselves the opportunity to process what we're feeling in the first place. And I think that's an important distinction. We don't necessarily need to suppress, ignore, or talk ourselves out of difficult emotions just because we know that positive thinking is supposed to be good for us. And as Paul says, it's not about turning everything into a positive, but acknowledging that when we're ready to, there's helpful ways of thinking and helpful things to pay attention to that we can move forwards, and one of those could be gratitude. It's also just interesting to note that in some life experiences, processing a difficult moment might take minutes, it might take hours, it might take days, or even longer than that, depending on what we're dealing with. But for athletes in some sports, particularly in competition, that window can be incredibly short. If you take a tennis player, for example, who's just hit a double fault at a crucial moment, they've got around 25 seconds before they need to step back up to the line and deliver their next serve. And there's not necessarily the time to work through every emotion in the way you might consider outside competition. And the challenge, therefore, is finding a way to acknowledge what's happened, respond helpfully, and get back to executing the next point. Much easier said than done, and lots of training and skill acquisition can help here. And if you need some tips on how to do it, grab a copy of the book and have a leaf through the chapters on responding and staying in the moment. One final thought is just being an enabler of belief in others. So there's a chapter in the book called Believing, and a lot of the chapter focuses on how you can help your belief in yourself, your self-confidence and your self-efficacy. But the chapter also touches on how to do that with others, which is really interesting. It's kind of touching on something that I think is hugely valuable, but something we don't really often think about enough, which is actively signposting the strengths of the people around us. Whether it's a colleague, a teammate, a friend, or a loved one, taking the time to tell someone what they're really good at or signpost what they've done well or what you genuinely appreciate about them. And that can have a much bigger impact than we might realise. It reminded of me of Peter Schneider's story from an earlier episode of Slice of Pie, talking about his experiences at RB Leipzig, where the media team filmed players highlighting each other's strengths and what they appreciated about them as teammates. And those videos were then shared with each player ahead, I think, of a big cup final. A brilliant example of utilising the authentic words of team members to build the belief and confidence in each other. And there's some interesting research to support this too, so Boothby and Bones in a 2021 paper found that people tend to massively underestimate the positive impact their compliments will have on others. In other words, we might think that a compliment is going to be relatively insignificant or perhaps even a little awkward, when in reality the recipient is likely to value it considerably more than we anticipate. There's also a nice well-being angle here as well. So research by Hugh and colleagues in 2020 in a meta-analysis of prosocial behaviour found modest benefits to the well-being of those engaging in acts of kindness and giving, so the people who are actually doing it. And interestingly, these benefits weren't just about feeling happier or experiencing positive emotions, which is what we might call hedonic well-being. They were particularly evident in eudaimonic well-being. So that's things like experiencing personal growth, having meaningful relationships, feeling that our actions are consistent with our values, and having a sense of purpose and contribution beyond ourselves. So, in short, if you can take that time to do things for others or signpost strengths in other people, engage in that type of prosocial behaviour. It's great for that person, but it's also helpful for ourselves as well. And I loved hearing Paul's own examples of putting this into practice, whether that's reaching out to former master students or podcast guests to share a compliment, highlight a strength, or simply just tell someone what he's appreciated about them. It was a nice reminder that these try this now tips aren't just things to write about in a book or talk about on a podcast, but they're things Paul is actively trying to live by himself. Big reflection this week. So there we have it. A conversation that offered a reminder that performing under pressure isn't always about finding another technique, developing another routine, or trying to eliminate uncomfortable feelings that come with doing something important. Sometimes it's just about being more deliberate about where we direct our attention, how we interpret what's happening inside us and what we choose to do next. And sometimes it's about looking beyond ourselves, recognizing the strengths in others and helping them believe in what they're capable of. And maybe instead of focusing ourselves to think positively all the time, even in the wake of challenging experiences that bring challenging emotions and cognitions. Perhaps just the humble goal of trying to think more helpfully can be a pretty useful place to start. So there we have it, folks. Stay tuned for the next slice of pie, which again will hopefully be hitting the airwave soon. We're on a bit of a roll at the moment. And if you have been, thanks for listening.
Podcasts we love
Check out these other fine podcasts recommended by us, not an algorithm.
Finding Mastery with Dr. Michael Gervais
Dr. Michael Gervais
The Focused Mind Podcast
focusedmindcoaching
Inside the Mind of Champions
Jeremy Snape
All in the Mind
BBC Radio 4
Supporting Champions
Steve Ingham